A lot of memes jumped on yesterday’s oil pipeline fire in the Gulf blaming things like capitalism or Exxon lobbyists. But the gas leak was from Pemex, the Mexican state-owned oil company. Pemex is an example of actual socialism in practice, not capitalism.
▪️Pemex says it took more than 5 hours to put out, but the fire now appears to be extinguished. Pemex blamed a gas leak from an underwater pipeline for sparking the blaze, although the Mexican oil regulators claimed the incident “did not generate a spill.” No injuries were reported.
https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/fire-offshore-pemex-platform-gulf-mexico-under-control-2021-07-02/
▪️Pemex was created in 1938 when the Mexican President signed an order expropriating the assets of foreign oil companies (mostly British and American) and barred any foreign oil companies from operating in Mexico. In other words, their government stole the equipment and effort of those companies and socialized their oil industry, much like other Middle Eastern nations and Venezuela did.
https://history.state.gov/milestones/1937-1945/mexican-oil
▪️Pemex has a long record of major accidents in its facilities and a terrible track record on pollution.
🔹In 1979, an explosion at their Ixtop well in the Gulf near the Texas coast was the largest oil spill at the time. Oil spilled for months. At the beginning, 30K barrels/day spilled into the Gulf. Pemex then pumped mud into their pipes, which only reduced it to 20K barrels/day. Relief wells were eventually drilled, reducing it to 10K/day, which was still catastrophic. 71,500 barrels washed up on US shores, polluting 162 miles of waterfront. This devastated the sea turtles in that region, taking decades to recover.
🔹In 1984, their poorly managed facility in Mexico City went up in flames, setting off a series of massive explosions killing more than 500 people. Another 200 were killed in an explosion in Guadalajara in 1992.
🔹Unguarded pipelines were attacked by Mexican terrorists in 2007, causing leaks and explosions. Later that year one of their rigs also collided with a drilling platform, killing 22 workers.
🔹Pemex dumped chemicals into the Coatzacoalcos River killing most of the fish and bankrupting local fishermen. During the worst periods, the river would catch fire every couple months. Nearby groundwater was also poisoned, leaving residents without drinking water or irrigation for farms.
https://books.google.com/books?id=Ko_mAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA139&lpg=PA139&dq=pemex+socialized&source=bl&ots=OQrxdohzx5&sig=ACfU3U2IqLuNdEkzOvI1Imzm3aDiLzgsMw&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjV85DjnsfxAhVKkWoFHTfRCaQQ6AEwEXoECBgQAw#v=onepage&q=pemex%20socialized&f=false
▪️When private companies have spills, they are generally held accountable for damages and reparations. For example, BP put aside $20B within weeks during their Deepwater Horizon spill in 2010. In contrast, Pemex invoked sovereign immunity and refused to pay almost anything in their Gulf spill.
▪️Similar stories occur with many state-run and socialized oil companies. There is seldom accountability, because it requires the government to punish itself. Good luck getting China to pony up money for damages if a SinoPec spill causes damage to your property or nation.
▪️But yet the belief still exists that it’s capitalism which is the source of pollution in the world. This sometimes reaches absurd evasions as with Chinese Communist Party officials who long claimed that pollution couldn’t exist in socialist countries because it was an “evil inherent in capitalism” even as they saw environmental devastation before them on a massive scale.
▪️The left keeps using this meme but they don’t actually believe it. If you believe SNAP subsidizes companies to pay below a “living wage” this implies that if you take food stamps away they would suddenly pay a higher, “living” wage. So why not get rid of food stamps, then?!
▪️Except they know, and everyone knows, this isn’t true. Wages are set by supply and demand, not some mythical “living wage” metric. Absent food stamps there would actually be downward, not upward, pressure on wages, because the reality is food stamps subsidize the poor to not work as much as they might otherwise need to.
▪️Without SNAP, some low income people would need to work more hours to make ends meet, increasing the availability of low-skilled labor and lowering wages (all else being equal).
▪️Plus, we all know the left loves and supports food stamps. Which means, by this meme’s logic, they love to subsidize corporate profits. But they don’t really, they just think this ...
▪️Wait, this is the guy libertarians and the new right rave about being a great historian?! This sounds like a clueless meme from The Other 98%, except they wouldn’t add in the bizarre defense of feudal lords. Feudalism didn’t deprive peasants of their livelihoods for abstract goals? This is total fantasy.
▪️Amazon employs 1.55M, so this is less than 2% of their workforce, although these cuts will be to corporate, which employs 350k, so 8.5% of that. The CEO says there is an excess of bureaucracy at Amazon, and AI can automate certain repetitive tasks. Also, much of the cuts will be to HR, which is expected shrink by 15%, yay. Managers and HR are peasants now?
▪️I don’t know the inner workings of Amazon, and neither does Darryl, but this seems to be normal management practice to keep a company efficient and competitive. Given the immense size of Amazon the numbers look large, but far bigger shakeups happen all the time in the private sector. Apparently, under the new ...
▪️This statistic is just made up. The reality is that there hasn’t been a real study on this since 2013, when Pew did a poll. They found that Democrats were actually more than twice as likely as Republicans to report ever using food stamps (22% vs 10%).
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2013/07/12/the-politics-and-demographics-of-food-stamp-recipients/
▪️Obviously, those percentages could have changed over the past decade, but it’s very likely that Dems still receive more SNAP benefits. Certainly, without an actual study or poll the claim should be thrown out, as it wildly contradicts a previous study.
▪️The meme probably comes from a 2024 analysis by Social Explorer, which found that 78.7% of US counties with the largest increase in SNAP since 2010 voted for Trump in 2020. But that tells us nothing about the actual number of Republicans (or Democrats) who are receiving benefits, just county-wide trends.
...